There’s no room for compromises when it comes to our skincare and beauty routines. No matter your age! In this article, I’m going to be reviewing the best eyeliner for older women, a beauty product, no doubt, that’s very rare to come across. And that’s quite surprising because the area around your eyes is the most likely to develop wrinkles and fine lines as you age.
So the liner formulation better be smudge-proof and waterproof for older eyes. Even the staying power of the eyeliners I’ve shortlisted below is pretty commendable. So let’s not waste any more time and get on with it right away!
10 Best Eyeliners for Mature Skin & Older Women
1. It Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
It Cosmetics is a brand to love, that’s for sure. As for their No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner, it glides on smoothly in the case of aged or mature skin. Plus, the liner stays in place for hours. Expect no pulling or tugging at the time of application.
Women over 50 don’t have the firm skin elasticity they once did when they were younger. So, at such times, it’s only natural to choose anti-aging specific beauty products, like this one.
2. Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner
Would you believe me if I told you that this eyeliner is allergy-tested, dermatologist-tested, and ophthalmologist-tested? Well, that is indeed true. And how many eyeliners have you come across that are suitable for sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses? Not many I’m assuming!
Anyway, the creamy gel formula lasts all day long. Its highly concentrated pigments highlight your eye makeup to create a dramatic look. Irrespective of how old you are!
I mean even if you’re 71 years old with eyelids that aren’t strong enough anymore for regular pencils, you can add a little bit of depth using a gel liner like this one that goes on effortlessly and is easy to control.
3. Physicians Formula Eye Booster 2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner Plus Serum
It’s not necessary that older women have spent most of their lives wearing eyeliner. You could be 65 years old and never have worn eyeliner before. It’s the easiest to apply with no amount of irritation.
It’s a hypoallergenic, dermatologist-approved makeup product. After all, the brand name is Physician Formula, so what do you expect!
Moreover, the eyeliner is easy to apply even on mature, old eyelids. The formula goes right over your eye wrinkles!
4. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil
Older women who have read or heard that they shouldn’t wear eyeliner as it makes their eyes and skin look older should definitely give this Urban Decay eyeliner pencil a try. The product, once applied, might not make you look any younger, but it certainly works quite well on aging or mature skin. And that’s very rare to come across!
The creamy formula gets on pretty smoothly for a long-lasting finish, in case you decide to go for a smokey eye look. In that case, why not incorporate the best under eye primer as well for keeping your eye makeup looking crease-free all day long!
5. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
As far as aging skin is concerned, waterproof eyeliner is a must. So why not consider buying the Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner by this American cosmetics brand Stila, which is actually the Swedish word for style.
The pen-like, ultra-precise tip is perfect for all the accuracy and control you demand if this is your first time using a liquid eyeliner, even at the age of 65. Speaking of which, it’s okay to be slightly hesitant to try eyeliner at that age. But, rest assured, this liner allows you to draw a thin line very easily, so you don’t look overly made up.
6. Jane Iredale Mystikol Powdered Eyeliner
Mystikol here is the most suitable for sensitive eyes. And for creating a much more flattering look than any other powdered eyeliner currently available. Jane Iredale is a very reliable brand when it comes to formulating makeup products that deliver all-day staying power.
This one’s equipped with coco glycerides, which allow you to apply the eyeliner smoothly with minimal effort. And it’s the inclusion of coco glycerides that also gives the liner the all-day staying power.
7. Marc Jacobs Gel Crayon Beauty Highliner
The best part about the Marc Jacobs Highliner is that it stays put when you want it to and comes off when you want it to. So, no doubt, the Gel Crayon stick is most likely to become your go-to eyeliner at whatever age.
The formula is so smooth and silky that application is nothing but a breeze. It goes on like butter, and maybe that’s why so many women don’t mind paying a large sum for this one.
8. Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil
Firstly, it’s an eye, brow, and lip pencil. Secondly, it glides on very smoothly. Thirdly, the staying power is not complain-worthy at all. And fourthly, if you’re young, then it’s highly recommended for you and your mother.
Plus, the travel-size makes the pencil a perfect addition to your on-the-go makeup arsenal inside your purse.
9. Givenchy Khol Couture Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner
Both the chestnut and black shades are vibrant-looking and smudge-free. You can use this waterproof eyeliner by Givenchy to highlight your eye makeup look with absolute precision.
The pigment-rich khol, in the case of black, is super-black. But both colors stay put for as long as 10 hours, at the end of which they’re easy to wash off.
10. Tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight
Now how about a vegan eyeliner for clean makeup enthusiasts? The Tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight is also an ophthalmologist-tested and dermatologist-tested product, thus safe for women who wear contact lenses.
Plus, it’s cruelty-free. Speaking of which, you might also want to have a look at these very popular cruelty-free brands for perfect-coverage foundations.
Moving on, the creamy gel eyeliner makes your eyes appear larger, thus more awake. And it has a long-wear, matte finish ideal for women of all ages.
Should You Use Eyeliner After 40 or 50?
Just because your skin is aging doesn’t mean you stop using your favorite makeup products. Instead, choose your products according to your mature skin. With wrinkles, fine lines, loss of skin elasticity, etc., it’s best to go for beauty formulations that don’t peel or smudge to keep from highlighting those creases.
So, of course, you can use eyeliner after 40 or 50, so long as the liner glides onto your lids smoothly. That means the formula should be able to go over your eye wrinkles too. And it ought to be infused with more natural and also moisturizing ingredients for protecting your delicate, aging skin from dryness and irritation, even your eyes.
If you don’t have to rub the liner too much in order to get it on, then know that it’s the most suitable for your skin condition.
What Color Eyeliner Is the Best for Older Women?
You can select just about any color as long as it doesn’t cause eye irritation. Some older women prefer using nude or white eyeliner since it tends to highlight the upper lids along with boldening and broadening the appearance of the eyes.
Even navy blue eyeliner looks very flattering as it looks good with almost everything you wear. Then come shades like plum, brunette, and brown for creating a more animated visual vibe.
And those that have dark circles under their eyes stay away from black eyeliners because they’re more likely to create more dullness around your eyes, thus making your dark circles even more visible.
How to Apply Eyeliner to Older Eyes?
Here are the instructions you might be looking for.
- You start, always, from the outer region of the eyes. And then gradually move toward your inner corners.
- What about your lower eyelids? The same applies; start from those outer corners, stopping in the center.
- Women who prefer the winged look, simply extend your eyeliner beyond your outer corners.
- As for a softer appearance, feel free to smudge the formula using your fingertip, an integrated smudge tool, or a cotton bud.
Factors to Keep In Mind When Choosing Eyeliner for Aging or Mature Skin
Now it’s time to cover the basics…
1. Types of Eyeliner
There’s the gel form, which is ideal for drawing both thick and thin lines. But gel liners are not easy to control. So if you’re new to this, then you might need extra practice. The upside though is that the gel formula lasts for a longer time and comes with extra-bold pigments.
Pencil eyeliners, on the other hand, give you all the control you desire. The newer pencil eyeliners don’t tug the skin like their older counterparts. In fact, the former is practically effortless to apply these days. And the most suitable for oily lids.
Then there are crayon eyeliners that are a combination of gel and pencil. With a relatively creamier consistency, they keep your skin from dryness. These are simply perfect for a smooth application and if you have dry eyelids.
The most popular liquid liners are smudge-proof and the easiest to control. No women, at any age, can go wrong with this kind.
Very rarely used, felt-tip or pen eyeliners are a cross between pencil and liquid. Mostly, women choose these for their highly pigmented formulation, maximum control, and long-wear staying power.
And last, but certainly not the least, is the powder eyeliner. It’s best for creating straight lines but not the most effortlessly. However, if you have oily lids, then these are the most fitting.
2. No-Tug Eyeliner
When you tug or pull aging skin, it only leads to more visibility of your lines and creases. On top of that, tugging gives rise to skin and eye irritation as well.
So whatever type of eyeliner you choose, make sure the formula is smooth and easy to glide on and remove without both applications compelling you to pull your skin.
3. Natural and Moisturizing Ingredients
I have reviewed an eyeliner infused with natural moisturizing or hydrating ingredients like jojoba oil and Vitamin E. Jojoba is for conditioning and softening the skin, especially dry skin. And Vitamin E for hydration, which is a must for activating anti-aging action.
These kinds of natural ingredients prevent any kind of eyelid or skin discomfort and irritation. On top of that, when the eyeliner is moisturizing too, it keeps your eyelids hydrated. And that, in turn, paves the way for easy, quick, and comfortable removal of your makeup.
And if you have sensitive eyes and/or skin, then choose hypoallergenic, dermatologist-tested, and ophthalmologist-tested formulas to keep irritation at bay. I myself have reviewed quite a few in this article.
4. Creates A Straight Line
Your eyeliner should be able to create a straight line over the lid. But this gets difficult to accomplish when there are wrinkles and creases on the surface. At such times, what helps a great deal is an eyeliner that’s smooth and effortless to apply.
5. Waterproof or Water-Resistant Eyeliner
As far as aging skin is concerned, waterproof eyeliner is a must. Especially if it’s a part of your daily beauty routine.
Also, waterproof or water-resistant formulas are the best for humid and rainy weather. They don’t smudge, meaning they stay in place until you remove them at the end of the day.
Those with wrinkles and fine lines should use an eyeliner equipped with an applicator in the form of either a precision-tip or felt-tip. The latter, in particular, is the best as it has thin and soft points for creating defined lines.
Then there are a few eyeliners that come with the smudge tool for a more dramatic effect.
Eyeliner Tips for Older Women
It doesn’t matter what type of eyeliner you choose, as long as you’re applying it the right way, you have nothing to worry about. Irrespective of how many wrinkles and fine lines you have!
Step 1 - Primer
Always use a primer over your cleansed eyelids before applying anything else. Then it’s time for your concealer to do its job of smoothening the eye area, so the eyeliner goes on smoothly.
Step 2 - Liquid Eyeliners Are the Best Choice
With age, it’s only natural for your upper eyelids to become more delicate or sensitive. So, at such times, the liquid version is the easiest to apply and control without any tugging or pulling at the time of putting it on and taking it off.
Step 3 - Go for White or Nude Eyeliners
These two are the safest colors for older women as they create a more flattering look. That said, your eyes are bound to look deep and beautiful.
Step 4 - Experiment with Colors
Now if you have dark circles, then make it a point to stay away from black eyeliner, unless you want to increase their visibility. Instead, choose shades like navy blue, plum, brunette, or brown.
Needless to say, the skin surrounding your eyes is the most delicate and even sensitive. In fact, with age, it’s bound to become more so. On top of that, wrinkles and fine lines begin to appear, which causes regular eyeliners and eye makeup to crease and smudge. So how about buying an eyeliner specifically formulated for mature skin!
It should be smooth, tug-free to apply and even wipe or wash off in order to keep skin and eye irritation miles away. And it would help a great deal if you choose a hypoallergenic, dermatologist-tested, and ophthalmologist-tested eyeliner.
And lastly, stay away from the black shade in case you have dark circles. Rather go for something more subtle like brown, nude, or plum.